Saturday, July 21, 2007

Charu's Dream Shattered

Charu was at danger zone today and she cant belief that she could be out of the Indian Idol.Even when the result was announced she appealed to the janta to give her a final chance. Charu told that this stage means a lot to her and she was not ready to leave it.
It was very pathetic to see that in every gala we are losing girls one by one. Just 3 girls left out of 7.This time all the 3 girls : Charu, Deepali and Puja was in danger zone.It's very shocking that inspite of the electrifying performance yestarday, Puja was in danger zone today.Although Prashant and Abshishek's performance was not that satisfactory,they were safe.

32 comments:

migo said...

I just want to say that , JANTA has voted out a right person , charu deserve it .Though it was unfair to see deepali in danger zone but for charu it was just fine. I dont know how the respectable judges compare boys with girls. Belive me its not the matter of boy & girl for which people vote , but boys REALLY sing very well. Their voices, their way of singing , nothing shuold be compared with girls . ONLY deepali deserves the best coments , judges sometimes give undue favour to ankita & she does not deserve it. & its my message for Annu Malik " Just ask yourself IS ANKITA BETTER THAN AMIT? " NOOOOOO WAYY , Amit Pauls is FAAAAR BEEETTTTEEER than Ankita but still they say ankita is as good as Amit. So these are my coments.

Tania said...

I agree with migo...and it shud be Amit, Deepali, Emon and Puja...good singers and definitely the fantastic four! I wish Ayesha was given a fair chance...bad politics there!

moona said...

i agree with both of them amit is the best singer more all of them charu is also nice and chamring girl but amit is such bomb.........

Fobb said...

Thanks for posting the news. I believe Charu is a terrible singer. She is definitely beautiful thats why she was getting farther. As far as the next three to go it has to parleen, prashant, and puja. I know alot of people like Puja but her voice is too young and it would sound awful in a movie on an actress such as Priyanka Chopra and Lara Dutta.

In my opinion the best four are Amit Ankita Abishek and Deepali. Please think of as Emon is a Sonu Nigam close, because he is. Emon will never win dude to the fact last years idol was Udit Naryan clone and his album sales sucked.

Thanks for a great site and I appreciate the quick updates. Other sites updates take too long and by that time the results are all over the news.

Terminator, Judgement Day!!! said...

Yes I too accept that voting out CHARU is fair enough, but the best would be having Prashanth, Abhishek, Chang & Charu in danger zone and then voting out Charu, (if depending on yesterday's performances only).

And yes, I agree with Migo's point..Amit is faaaaaar better than not only Ankitha, but many other contestants also.

But how can we generalize that all boys are doing gud, did really Prashanth (infact cute Chang too) had given any outstanding perfomance from the past 3 weeks..??? I can not digest the fact that Deepali in danger zone & Prashanth,Chang,Abhishek sitting there happily !!!!!!!!!!!

Priyantha De Silva said...

I'm in Sri Lanka.

We SMS Indian Idol to the number 0091-2525 and, it works.It's not fair to out Charu till Top 5 are selected.She has a great talent , Just at 19.
All the TOP 12 are great. But to the law , we have to face the sad moments till the Super Star is selected.

My blog address is,
http://starlanka.blogspot.com

Dr.Samreen said...

hmm i think prashant or abhishek has to be voted out instead of charu... charu has a good voice but she had not selected good songs for singing... as far as ankita is concerned she is struggling so hard but her voice quality is not good enough as compared to amit's ( agreed with Migo ).The top 3 are Amit, deepali and ankita

bhavesh said...

ye bhut galt hua he charu ke shath kyuki uar bhi bhut log ne galt gaya tha fir bhi caru kyu vese asa ho na chahi ye ke aakhari feshla jaj ka hona chahia aur log ka vote 25% tak ka hisha ho na chahia.

Heart said...

Listen Friends...
Ankita used her influences to come back to Indian Idol...! Think about it, What she has quality to compare other girls in Indian Idol. she always sings same kind of Masti songs, Thats all...! I dont say she is bad singer but that is truth she can only sing only certain songs.
since she came back none of the Judges said a single word against her. cuz they CANT..! You all adults & understand what could possible in Bollywood Politics..!
hmmmm Minister Dhamki easiy control those simple judges.

meranaamjokar said...

CHARU WAS MY FAVOURITE PARTICIPANT AND I DIDNT EXPECT THAT SHE WILL BE ELIMINATED YESTERDAY.I REALLY ADMIRED HER AND SHE WAS A COOL GIRL.

Annu said...

i want to say that, JANTA has to wait for 2 more Ghala's for Charu, this is really not fare, i think charu is better than Deepali and Puja, charu deserves to be TOP 5 in indian idol, i think indian idol results should change their way of voting, instead of JANTA voting you should give some of the Music Directors to vote.........

mohd shakir said...

This is really unfair.A big blow to indian idol.She was really a very good singer.

mohd shakir said...

This is really unfair.A big blow to indian idol.She was really a very good singer.

mani said...

I Just Want to say that, Chang did'n give a good performance,still he was not in the danger Zone, & Puja....She gave her outstanding performance, & she was in danjer Zone?????
If Judges are given a power to give points, & there are 50% votes for Janta & 50% Votes for judges, than the competition will give a good Indian Idol to India....
That's all.Thank You.

fahm said...

Prashant should have been voted out instead of Charu...
and
i would say Ankhita is a great singer PLUS performer.. u can tell that she gave her all in all her performances..
stop dissing her!

xpikon said...

I dont know y u Indians voted out Charu instead of Parshant, he is not singing well from last 2 Gala round. We loose Charu for Pashant....We loose Smitha for Parleen(as he didnt sang well in that Gala round)

raj said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
uffan said...

i dont know what perashant is doing and what the hell perline in doing there these two guys should leave the compitition. in boys only the bast singe is amit he sings great than coms the chang and in girls arkita is best when she sings in mood it looks great. and definately arkita will be this time indian idol. same is for amit.

Anil Kumar said...

Dear Sony TV ,

It is prooven that the system followed to vote out a contestent is not suiting to Indian's thinking as they vote as per their region / state , it is high time Sony TV should draw out a formal .

May be they should design a formula to get ratio between votes counted from contestent home state to all indian voting . Based on ratio of votes secured by the contestent , he / she has to be voted in or out .

This being Indian Idol the all India voting has to be given high priority rather than regional voting .

Anil Kumar said...

Are you hearing Sony TV.

Narinder said...

Hi,

I think Janta has voted out a right person 'Charu' on friday. Infact there were many other candidated who were far better than her who got eliminated in earlier round like Smita and Richa. Charu has come so far to a certain extent becuase of her good looks. Her friday performance was terrible and Janta is not a fool who will vote for a person on the basis of looks.
And just imagine she was not ready to go saying that this Platform means a lot to her , i have say only that Indial Idol Platform means and meant alot to every one who r there in show and who have already got eliminated.
So dear Charu better concentrate on ur singing next time

Narinder kaur (Mumbai)

chandan said...

I am chandan mazumdar
I just want to say that, this is really wrong, a big blow to Indian idol . she was really a very very good sinser .
I dont know what Prashant is doing and Parleen also in doing there, these two guys should leane the compitition.we loose Smita for Parleen ....We loose Charu for prashant.that is all.

girish said...

I just want say that prashant should have been voted out in this gala round. Charu would have been gone in later rounds anyway I am glad she's gone, that girl has a big ego thinking she better than deepali. I think the best three are amit,ankita and amon.

xpikon said...

I think Sony TV should revise their show format and change the rule. the new rule is of at least 60% marks from Judges and other 40% from so called JANTA. wht do u say guyz???

Venkatram said...

feel sorry for Charu.......
jantha cannot be ignored ...though how biased it may sound...
all the best for yr future

Shann said...

I think prashants performance was really bad, he shuld have been voted out.

Puru said...

Hi Charu

Please emphasis on singing quality otherwise you will be out. I personally thing that "Public Kisi Ki Sagi Nahin", So please concentrate on singing not about looks.

Keep up Ankita and Amit, bcoz they both knows what will be the wild card entry.

So plz do something CHARU

gurinder said...

u all r maaaaad and bloody politicians .............

charu did not deserves t be out tht day...... bcoz he performs well tht day,,,,,,

Avinaya said...

I don't know why so many people are against Prashant - is it his Nepali look or is it the lack of comic 'physical performance' that other participants exibit? I honestly feel that Prashant has the most natural talent and sings with unaffected innocence and beauty. I am sure the all powerful janta will make him the new Indian Idol. Good luck Prashant.

sugra said...

it was pretty fair for charu 2b out coz there r better singers than her.amit rocks n ankita is cool as usual,emon n chang r nevertheless.i think next prashant or pooja has 2 go coz i find pooja a bit kiddish n prashant lacks x factor.abhishek is just a fair singer n parleen is not bad at all.sry 2 say bt i find deepali too boring.I WISH AMIT WINS COZ HE REALLY DESERVES IT

Neha said...

Thats not fair thats bear sad she was a really really good singer the janta didnt do very good

Rida said...

Charu was a terrible singer and she deserves it