Monday, September 17, 2007

AMIT VS PRASHANT ? Who Will Win The Crown!!



ABOUT AMIT PAUL

This struggling singer had given up his studies to pursue his passion. When the chance to participate in Indian Idol came along, Amit Paul thought it was a godsend. But his dreams seemed to be in danger of dying even before they matured. He was voted out early in the show.
But he got a second lease of life through a wild card entry. And there has been no looking back since. This perfectionist is now in the finals. Will the `find of Indian Idol`, as the judges call him, be crowned the winner.


ABOUT PRASHANT TAMANG

The police is all about duty, force and action. Not an ambience that nurtures a singer. But this sepoy beat all odds (no formal training in music is a huge factor) to make it to the Indian Idol stage. The first Nepali to ever take part, Prashant Tamang soon had everyone wrapped around his little finger. His fans were so enthusiastic in voting for him that he has never been in the danger zone till date. Negative comments from the judges only spurred him on to do better. Now he has proven his worth and he is in the Top 2.

58 comments:

samir said...

PRASHANT IS REALLY CAPABLE AND HAVE THE TALENT,THOUGH NO FORMAL TRAINING HE IS DOING VERY GOOD.

anup said...

I agree with Samir, Amit was my Idol first but after seeing the mumbai cafe round and the last gala, Prashant was really good. I mean he was better than my idol. I congratulate him, despite all bias eyes prying on him. I felt the judges were bias in the last gala and sony was concerntrating too much on Amit. This I really didn't like. I liked Anu Malik's comment. My view point has changed. Though both are good singers, but I feel Prashant has proved himself and we should respect that. I am for Prashant.

Rajat said...

hey parsant .. keep it up man ... u r the hope of upcoming generation .. and prey 4 u man ... !



the generation to the next.................

Desi Pundit said...

I'm slightly biased in favor of prashant but am ok with either winning the crown.

I'm especially happy that the peripheral states of Meghalaya, Assam and Sikkim and of course the Darjeeling region has been cast into the limelight.

Even if they are voting for their state-ka-aadmi, they are ultimately voting for an all-India crown. That feeling of comnection with the Indian heartland I think was the sinbgle biggest achievement of the show. No amount of govt sponsored publicity or paens or propaganda could have wrought what this show has brought - a feeling of nationalism, belonging, self-belief and happiness in the folks of these smaller states of India.

Welcome aboard, folks!

Preeti said...

Hey,

Both Amit and Prashant are good. However, I feel Amit's performance is more lively. Initially I wanted both Amit and Prashant to reach the finals. However, I cant resist favouring Amit.

I think he is a true idol, coz like all of us he has made mistakes, but has lerant from them n excelled.

So,I think Amit should win.
Now its not upto 2 us to decide who wins and who loses, who ever has got it in his destiny will win.

Best of luck to both Amit and Prashnt but in my heat i want Amit 2 win.

honey said...

i think prashant shud win an indian idol......we all know tht he is really a gud singer and wid such a great personality........AND I HATE THT B**** ALISHA

Rahul said...

Prashant will win this the crown of indial idol because he is the upcoming singer and a good solder too so we should vote for him
every sat and sun i used to vote him arround 60-70 times so if i can do that much y dont you can do atleast 2 for sat and sun keep voting him and lets ROCK with Prashant

Wish you all the Best Prashant from me and from all the people who likes your singing

Take Care

caramel said...

ofcourse prashant will win da titel..............after watching da last episode.........m surely goin 2 vote for prashant..........
PLZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ PPL VOTE FOR PRASHANT..........HE REALLY DESERVES 2 WIN.HE LUKS SOOOOOOO INNOCENT

BABYLUV said...

prashant n amit they both r gud singers,but after watchin tht gala round i think prashant iz better than amit,ill goooooo fooooooooo PRASHANT............PRASHANT ROCKS

rabi said...

rabi
i really think amit should be the next idain idol not bcz i like amit its bcz he has a great voice like old famous singers prashant is also good i like him he sings very good but if he become indian idol that wont be fair to amit coz he really deserves to be an indian idol even when he sings without the music his voice is just great i dnt knw much abt indian music n im also not idain but i like to listen to indian music n a little bit that i knw i really think amit should win.

nritya said...

Well i really appreciate wat Desi has written...i have similar opinions regarding the feeling of the peoples that has been generated as Amit and Prashant reached the top two slot.The people of North East and Darjeeling has really connected with the rest of India and it is great feeling for everyone .Whoever wins the grand finale ,in a way it will be a reason of celebration out there for people of two regions.....Long way to go for both talented singers.

Krishna Dai said...

Great news for all Prashant fans, lets celebrate!!! Prashant is leading by a very large number of votes and there is no way that Amit can catch up.

dhruva said...

BOTH AMIT AND PRASHANT ARE VERY GOOD SINGERS.BUT PRASHANT IS MORE A VERSATILE SINGER....HE SINGS FROM THE HEART....AND IN HIS VOICE LIES THE ORIGINALITY THOUGH SOME TO EXTEND ROUGH AND TOUGH.... SO FOR ME PRASHANT HAS GOT THE EDGE...

DHRUVA SHARMA
batasialoop@yahoo.com

rinkola said...

definatelly AMIT PAUL will win this crown.. he is very telented..n his singing is very good n his voice is touching the heart...
i vote for amit

Prashant said...

Please I BEG U ALL VOTE FOR PRASHANT. He is so cute, so sweet so innocent, so pure, so naive, so...whatever

dhruva said...

DEAR FRENS,
I WOULD SAY PLEASE VOTE FOR PRASHANT...
HE IS A BETTER SINGER THAN AMIT...
PRASHANT VOICE IS AMAZING! HE IS TOO GOOD..

VOTE FOR PRASHANT

DHRUVA SHARMA
dhruva.sharma@yahoo.co.in

Prashant said...

Prashant is so naive, harmless, unsophisticated, unworldly, artless, childlike, gullible, ingenuous, pure, simple

sexy babe said...

I VOTE FOR PRASHANT
dis is 4 RABI,well ya think tht it will b fair for prashant if amit wins? I LIKE BOTH OF DEM BUT M MORE INTO PRASHANT,i like more prashants voice,it sounds soo unique.

dhruva said...

Dear all,
I like Prashant's voice more. He is a better and more versatile a singer and could handle any type of song.It is after all the cellular power which is working behind the results. Yes, It is a fact that Prashant is the lad next door and deserves appreciation for bringing about tremendous improvement in his singing and style despite of the fact that his accent and pronunciation is a matter of concerned. His singing shows effortless unlike that of Amit Paul whose singing shows lot of stress and heavy...

VOTE FOR PRASHANT

DHRUVA SHARMA

Arnaz said...

Amit Paul, u r the ONLY person who deserves 2 b Indian Idol 3. U hav ALWAYS been my favourite contestant and i pray tht u become Indian Idol 3. I dont care wht the results r, u n only u r MY idol! All the best 2 u! i luv u! prashant has come till top 2 n thts more than enough 4 him. he duznt deserve tht posotion n has no right of becoming indian idol. bharat ki shaan ka sawaal hai. koi bhi chindi chor thode hi bharat ki shaan ban sakta hai.

Prashant said...

I'M NUTS ABOUT YOU U DRIVE ME CRAZY U DRIVE ME MAD

dhruva said...

Hey Arnaz,
Please mind your words.It doesnot who u vote for but please do not start the dirty blame game...
I love prashant's vote thats why i vote him but that does not mean that i hate amit..

ok
Dhruva

Prashant said...

vote for your community vote for your state

Amit said...

East or West Amit is the Best!
Go Amit we are with you..... Hey guys open your eyes, heart and mind. lookkkkkkk Amit is better singer over prashant it's clear like water. . . dont try to act like you are blind.....Even though prashant wins indian idol title because of regional voting he wont be able to make his career in Music industry. on the other hand Amit will rule music industry as all the judges are with Amit and the most important thing is even Bollywood is with Amit... so open your eyes NOW>.......

Amit said...

hey dhruva....... open your eyes...
why you dont see that Amit can sing all kind of songs as Javedji, Anu Malik, Sonu Nigam, Alish chinai, Udit Narayan said he is the best. No one wants prashant to come to even top 5. prashant can sing only certain kind of songs Vs Amit can sings all the songs from Kishor Kumar TO Kunal Ganjwal... so dhruva beti please open your eyes and vote for correct candidate..... lolzzz

xpikon said...

Pershant might be a good singer without a training but the fact is Amit has too much versatilely than Pershant.

nritya said...

Hello Amit,
U seem to be great fan of Amit Paul and i can understand u being be so vocal about the fact that he should win the Indian Idol.But why are under rating Prashant....Do u really think that he has just reached the top slot because of this votes.......Ohhh c'mon if u just go through your old geography book (if u have ever seen Indian Map)u will see that North East from where Amit hails is far more bigger than Darjeling.Now u are talking of all those goddamm regional voting ......if its so then Amit is also getting his fair share of votes from his region...Now talking of rest of India its clear they are voting for the one whom they think should be next Indian Idol.U also know that they will not see the background .If the rest of India want Amit to be the chosen one then leave it to them,u just stop saying things about Prashant.
Coming to the versatality of these two singers why do u think that Amit is the only one who has this quality?Yes he has flawless voice but so has Prashant....both have improved a lot and on a par they are both equal.Let me remind you both are amauteurs and both are improving.
Prashant has done faboulous job till now.If u like Amit then dont go around telling Prasahnt is bad singer.We all know he is also very very good one.
Just because u like Amit u dont have the right to say Prashant is good for nothing.Just do one work vote for Amit and we will do it for Prashant.
And in the future do change ur way of judgement.

Krishna Dai said...

http://www.tamangsamaj.com/displaynews.php?cid=98

Krishna Dai said...

Nepalis in Darjeeling, Kurseong, Sikkim... are going to be bankrupt by the end of this show SUCKERS for punishment

Lee Parker said...

Amit is better singer and I will love to see him as the Bharat Ki Shaan but Prashant has a greater chance of winning the titile as Prashant is getting the votes of Calcutta Police as well as from people of Darjeeling. If Prashant wins the title then Indian Idol 3 will be a flop show as Indian Idol 2. Just see what happened to Indian Idol 2 -- Sandeep......Even the Sony channel didn't took the risk of calling him while they call Abhijit Sawant, Indian Idol 1 for twice. This will happen to Prashant if he becomes the Indian Idol. At this point of the show his untrained voice has become very prominent. Amit Paul will surely make mark in the industry whether he becomes the Indian Idol or not!

Kareena said...

Oscar Wilde
Of course the music is a great difficulty. You see, if one plays good music, people don't listen, and if one plays bad music people don't talk.

Ron Wood
There's a basic rule which runs through all kinds of music, kind of an unwritten rule. I don't know what it is. But I've got it.

Yoko Ono
All my concerts had no sounds in them; they were completely silent. People had to make up their own music in their minds!

Frank Zappa
There are more love songs than anything else. If songs could make you do something we'd all love one another.

Kareena said...

I bet if you asked one million musicians and music experts about who was the worst male singer on American Idol these past few episodes, one million of them would say Sanjaya.

Why is this happening? Why is anyone voting for Sanjaya? I could understand it if he were the reverse Antonella, but I really can't imagine that Sanjaya is going to inspire adulation from the ladies. Please, comment below if I'm wrong, but his looks can't be the reason for the votes he is getting. The only thing I can think of is that it has to do with his ethnicity.

Jim said...

I dont believe people should be baise on ethinicity. Yes, sometime it is the ground. Amit is very good singer, and has shown that with his selection of different language songs. He has lured judges and impressed many viewers. But Prashant has constantly shown the reliable and magical voice which is so simple and soothing that million can relate to. Also, for the fact that he is so simple and careing. Many people relate to him as their own. He should be the idol because he represents India, todays India where simple person with no high caste or connection can do it and be there. Therefore Prashant must win to show how open minded India and Indians are. Vote for Prashant

Jim said...

I also think if Amit wins (there is a fair chance he might) then Sony Ent. will be tarnished with bais judges and host for the show. Is this what they want to risk? After such a popularity with media and phone sms money.
It is 50-50 in pure math but I still think Prashant will win and must win. Vote for Prashant.

anchal said...

AMIT IS THE BEST AND I AM DAM SURE HE IS GOING TO WI AS HE CAN SING ALL TYPES OF SONGS
HIS BEST ONE WAS-MANN

jinal said...

i am with u amit jst go on with ur eyes closed n keep trust in god u will win u r my idiol.ok keep it up amit lu v

Kareena said...

The voters can be wrong. Often they vote for the wrong political party. So what’s so unusual about them voting for the wrong singer? Javed asked on the show.

ank said...

prashant try your perfection in your duty not in singing i am not doing comment on ur siging but your duty is duty

sexyluv said...

PRASHANT IZ A GR8 SINGER N HE WILL B AN INDIAN IDOL NO MATTER WHT DIS MOTHFUCKA LOSERS SAYS ABT HIM.......F*** U ALL PRASHANT HATERS:::::::::::::go 2 HELL//////////N LEMME TELL YA'llll
AMIT SUCKSSSSS................BIG TIME

sexyluv said...

VOTE PRASHANT
VOTE PRASHANT
VOTE PRASHANT
VOTE PRASHANT

srijana said...

prashant wll win the crown... he is excellent... all the luck prashant dai!!!

santsoh said...

I think PRASHANT shud win yepp he sud deffinately win the indian idol 3 coz his got a gr8 voice and personality and also amit is gud singer anyway prashant is capable for this crown........this is 4 ARNAZ oi who the HELL u callin chindi chor HUH mind ur language think before u talk ...hears a quoate 4 u-chhote walle chotte bat kartehe samaj gaye....but remember u just can't go around talkin like that learn to respect othas thoughts

MUBASHAR said...

Hi PRASHANT I am Mubashar Ahmad From Pakistan Wish You Best I Love You & You Will Win The Indian Ideol

dhruva said...

DEAR ALL,
PRASHANT IS MORE A VERSATILE SINGER THAN AMIT.IN HIS VOICE LIES THE ORIGINALITY WHICH IS VERY MUCH REQUIRED IN PRESENT DAYS OF COPYCATS...
FOR ME PRASHANT IS A BETTER CHOICE

VOTE FOR PRASHANT

DHRUVA

dhruva said...

IN THIS ERA OF SMSes NO ONE CAN PREDICT THE ONE WHO WILL BE ON THE TOP... BUT ONE THING IS SURE PRASHANT HAS GOT MUCH MUCH VERSATALITY AND HAS GOT THE ORIGINALITY IN HIS VOCAL... THIS IS WHAT I THINK..
PRASHANT PRASHANT ALL THE WAY...
DHRUVA
NEW DELHI

dhruva said...

WE ARE PROUD OF PRASHANT-NEPALI BOY FROM DARJEELING WHO HAS DONE A BIG BIG FAVOUR BY UNITING ALL THE NEPALESE PEOPLE RESIDING IN INDIA OR ABROAD.THIS IS AWESOME.KUDOS TO PRASHANT .... WE NEPALI SPEAKING PEOPLE ARE TREATED NOT IN A NICE MANNER IN INDIA... BEST EXAMPLE LOOK THE WAY PRASHANT IS BEING TREATED BY THE JUDGES OR CELEBRETIS..BUT OUR BRAVE PRASHANT HAS GOT A AMAZING PATIENCE AND GUTS OVERCOMING ALL THESE AND NOW HE IS ON THE TOP... LETS HOPE FOR THE BEST...

VOTE FOR PRASHANT
sms PRASHANT to 52525

Dhruva
Delhi & Darjeeling

dhruva said...

P- POLICE
R- ROUGH AND TOUGH
A- AMAZING VOICE
S- SIMPLICITY
H- HONOURABLE
A- AWESOME GUTS
N- NEPALI HERO
T- TALENTED

VOTE FOR PRASHANT

DHRUVA
DARJEELING

jayarapu said...

AMIT IS BEST IN EAST AND WEST

suresh said...

AMIT IS THE BEST

lineonfire said...

AMIT paul u r a real winner n in no time will be play back singer....prashant |!!!!!!!!!!!!!!it was reallly unfair...hey guys how can u people judge a winner only in one of his performance...i think parshant should not b even into the finals he s here as becoz hes a police men n india want to boost his army n police..sorry guys but india idol z not a fair programme iff public has tod ecide then y they need judged...public has no real sense of music they vote for enjoyment...

L.A/BT said...

Priya Prashant bhai,

Mo euta kunama bhayoko cheli aja hajurko bijayata dekhara yeti khusi chu ki aja samma yesto khusi maile payeko thina tara aja timile garda hami sabai hill ma basne manis haru, sampurna police force r napali jatiko seer uchha gari deu. Dherai dherai dhanya bad timi lai. Na samjinu ki hamro sayeta ley matrai timi aja yo stanma prabes garna paeu bhanera. Timi jasto talented bhai theu ra matrai aja hamiley pani utinai khusi payeka chau jati timiley. Aba hami chahanchau ki timi ajai kosis gara ra agadi badera timro afno ama, dedi bahini afantaharu r Darjeeling, Kalimpong, Sikkim, Nepal, Bhutan ma baso baso garney sampurna police force, timro subchintak haru r nepali jatiko nam ajai roshan garideu. Kosis gara ajai agadi bada yehi nai hamro khusi ho.

Special thanks to your boss. We should treat him as our god father. Kinabhaney aja uniley garda nai hamiley eti khusi payeka chau.

Jai hind.....

L.A/BT

janice mukhia said...

To “ALL” you Prashant and Nepali Haters.......BOHOOOOOOOO. Look who got the last laugh now.

Amit was a strong contender no doubt BUT it was Prashant's talent that came shining through. Like it or not, he "IS" deserving of this victory. His unflinching confidence, humility and undeniably calm demeanor further reflects the nobility that lies in him.

I am confident this is just the beginning of his stardom. Prashant, I wish you continued success. Thanks for making "ALL" the Nepalese around the world extremely proud. You showed your worst critics the true essence of your calibre. If this is a matter of challenge, we Nepalese will once again step up to the challenge and see to it that he succeeds.

Regardless, Prashant you “ARE” the Indian Idol and we’re extremely proud of you.

To that ignorant girl who called him a "chindi" in an earlier post....honey you have a long way to go before "intelligence" in any form will even come remotely close to you. That was an IGNORANT, irresponsible comment that speaks volumes about your upbringing, your intelligence, your immaturity and your educational background. I pity you because your choice of words has displayed your lack of intelligence and maturity in front of the whole world.

Prashant is not a looser; Nepalese are not loosers...YOU my dear need to come off your cocoon and open your eyes to the realities of life.

In this era, where we live in a global village...if that is what your true sentiments are, you will discover (very soon if I might add) how pathetically incorrect you are. India is a cauldron of mixed cultures and ethnicities. Just because someone looks or speaks differently than you does NOT mean he/she is beneath you. So step out of your comfort zone...don't cling to negative stereotypes...because the world has moved ahead. It is time for you to either catch up or be left behind.

Regards,


Maili.
A HARDCORE Nepali from Darjeeling currently in the U.S.

Anuj said...

To ARNAZ....

Chindi Chor hoga tera baap.

..

btw, PRASHANT WON!!!!!!!

hehe

nathan said...

Dude! No matter what winning matters in the end. I don’t know why it is soooooooooooooo hard for you to except Prashant as a winner of Indian Idol 3. And who the hell are you to verdict that Prashant doesn’t deserve to be Indian Idol????
It appears that you really have a good taste for music and perhaps you could really prove to be a good judge. You know greatest rock stars and pop stars were laughed at like Bob Dylan, Elvis Presley etc.
And Please refrain from using that cheap phrases which sux big time.

Nepali Music said...

To Arnaz:

Mother fuc-ker arnaz, behen chod, chindi chor kis ko bolta hai, teri puri family me randi log hai kya. ishi leye tera soch is down like the nali ke kere. fcuk you arnaz, fcuk you and your whole family.

Hey rest of India, see how this arnaz has violated our right to freedom and speech. we had to answer him, this guy is racist and is discriminating. once again, tere purey family ko chodne ke leye tayar hoo mein.

prateez said...

Stop cribbing !! You knew this was a contest where a winner would be selected by the number of votes they received.

If you preferred other contestants over Prashant then you could have voted any number of times to have your favorite on stage as there was no restriction...was there?? Or were your hands tied ? See no one stopped you from voting ; so why complain now? What's done cannot be undone and Prashant has got immense support from ALL NEPALI SPEAKING PEOPLE - and for those of you who think Darjeeling has only people from Nepalese origin then you are highly mistaken. There is much unity amongst the various ethnic backgrounds - marwaris, tibetans, nepali, bengali,bihari, sherpas just to name a few - and this contest just proved it. They voted because this lad represented them and because they believed he could prove himself as a singer. And he did ! It is no mean feat to be up on stage among such talented/trained singers and with his undaunted courage and our belief in him, Prashant is now the third Indian Idol !

There is no denying that Amit is a better singer and since he is one -there will be no looking back for him as he has already carved a niche for himself - so people why fret? It is just a competition and it was up to us to choose our Idol and we chose ours !

Maybe this will be a learning experience for the next season?

lijialefw said...

Found two good games Dollar (wow gold) deal! (wow gold) Are cheap! Blue is very good, you may wish to enter the site to its own needs of the trading game coin! (wow gold) Is also available in Dailian game! (wow power leveling)This station is also available wow power levelingwow powerleveling wow power leveling buy rolexof World of Warcraft gold

Indian hot actress sexy photo gallery said...

Visit>>>

.
.
.
.
.
Top 100 best beautiful smart girls with sexy style



.
..
.
.


Exclusive sexy bra Aunties hot photo in 2 pieces



Indian hottest actresses exclusive photo at wet collection



Sexy world best cleavage exclusive photo gallery


.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
>>>>>

For More Sexy Hot worldest best celebrities Photo At about 8400 Exclusive
.
.
.
.
.
.
..